Isn't It Rich

"He who shall introduce into public affairs the principles of primitive Christianity will change the face of the world." Benjamin Franklin

Friday, July 22, 2005

"Reality and Islam"


Columnist Diana West

Diana West, after receiving criticism for an earlier column, Facing hard facts, defends her comments about the fallacies of multiculturalism in her most recent column, Reality and Islam:

As conservatives, JWR columnist Charles Krauthammer and blogger-cum-radio host Hugh Hewitt still fight the good fight, but, in these multicultural days, that means sorting through "extremism" and finding nothing too terribly Islamic about it. Mr. Hewitt writes that my arguments of last week were wrong, citing "functioning democracies in Turkey and other predominantly Islamic countries" as evidence of Islamo-Western compatibility. He throws in the loyal host ("millions of loyal British and American citizens") for good measure. Problem is, the extent to which Turkey — where, just incidentally, "Mein Kampf" was a top 10 bestseller this spring — has ever functioned as a democracy is directly related to the efforts of a strong man, Ataturk, to constrain Islam's grip on the country's institutions, replacing religion with a doctrine of Turkish racial and civilizational supremacy. And while it tugs on the heartstrings, the loyalty of individual Muslims fails to neutralize or reform the institutions of jihad and dhimmitude that rise from Islamic teachings. That I even raised the issue, Mr. Hewitt writes, "underscores the almost desperate need for Muslim leaders in the West again and again, to denounce, without argument or sidebar mentions of Israel, etc., the use of terrorism as a weapon." Almost desperate is right.

Having determined that "99 percent" of European Muslims are "peace-loving and not engaged in terror," Charles Krauthammer sounds a similar alarm. "They must actively denounce not just ... the terrorist attacks, but their source: the Islamist ideology and its practitioners. Where are the fatwas against Osama bin Laden? Where are the denunciations of the very idea of suicide bombing? Europeans must demand this of all their Muslim leaders."

Why Europeans? Why not the Krauthammer 99 percent, or the Hewitt millions? This is where it gets tricky, where those cultural ties to terrorism's tactics and/or goals seem to be all too binding. It is true that in March, something called the Spanish Muslim Council issued a fatwa against Osama bin Laden, calling him an apostate for his atrocities. Judea Pearl, father of slain journalist Daniel Pearl, mentions this in his Boston Globe piece about a clerically star-studded conference on Islam in Jordan this month. Mr. Pearl notes that the fatwa led many to believe it would be followed by others, "and," he writes, "that using the Islamic instruments of fatwa, apostasy and fasad (corruption), Muslims would be able to disassociate themselves from those who hijacked their religion."

He continues: "Unfortunately, the realization of these expectations will need to wait for a brave new leadership to emerge. The final communique of the Amman conference, issued July 6, states explicitly: 'It is not possible to declare as apostates any group of Muslims who believes in Allah the Mighty and Sublime and His Messenger (may Peace and Blessings be upon him) and the pillars of faith, and respects the pillars of Islam and does not deny any necessary article of religion.'"

Mr. Pearl spells out the chilling ramifications: "In other words, belief in basic tenets of faith provides an immutable protection from charges of apostasy." Even what Mr. Pearl calls "anti-Islamic behavior," including "the advocacy of mass murder in the name of religion, cannot remove that protection," he writes. "Bin Laden, Abu Musab al-Zarqawi and the murderers of Daniel Pearl and Nick Berg will remain bona fide members of the Muslim faith, as long as they do not explicitly renounce it."

Which leaves conservative Muslims, liberal Muslims and everybody else between a rock and hard place. Isn't it time to crack things open?

|

<< Home

Flags

Previous Posts

  • Outrageous Behavior in Sudan
  • Time to stop making excuses
  • John Fund: "To Roberts' Opponents, the Constitutio...
  • The Real Suicide Bomb
  • The Fun Begins!
  • Quote of the Day
  • This Day in History
  • Fumento Blasts Schwarzenegger
  • Quote of the Day
  • Happy Golden Anniversary, Disneyland!
Be sure to visit Born To Win's Weekend Bible Study; a scintilating look into the very Word of God...never boring!

Bible Verse Du Jour

News and Info

  • u s constitution
  • the whitehouse
  • official u.s. time
  • this day in history
  • library of congress
  • state of texas
  • nasa
  • fema
  • accuweather
  • smithsonian institution
  • the british museum
  • getty museum
  • huntington library
  • reagan library
  • museum of science and industry
  • guggenheim museum
  • vatican museums
  • word of the day
  • bartleby-great books online
  • drudge
  • breitbart
  • breitbart's biggovernment
  • breitbart-tv
  • breitbart's big hollywood
  • pajamas media
  • lucianne
  • ann coulter
  • worldnetdaily
  • the hill
  • investor's business daily
  • realclearpolitics
  • freerepublic
  • agape press
  • breitbart
  • breitbart/tv
  • the news right now
  • the politico
  • bill gertz
  • crisscross news
  • lexisnexis news
  • happy news.com
  • ananova
  • fox news
  • cnn
  • sky news
  • bbc news
  • c-span
  • american petroleum institute
  • american enterprise
  • human events
  • national review
  • weekly standard
  • reason
  • iconoclast
  • american spectator
  • commentary
  • d magazine
  • texas monthly
  • frontpagemag
  • discoverthenetwork (a guide to the political left)
  • city journal
  • american thinker
  • intellectual conservative
  • tech central station
  • scientific american
  • livescience
  • fast company
  • 9/11 families for a secure america
  • townhall
  • jewish world review
  • jerusalem post
  • haaretz
  • ynet news
  • newsmax
  • opinion journal
  • google news
  • cnsnews
  • conservatives4palin
  • insight
  • chronwatch
  • time
  • us news and world report
  • mensnewsdaily
  • radio daily news
  • talkradio daily news
  • eagle forum
  • homemakers for america
  • department of defense
  • center for science & culture
  • sovereignty international
  • center for consumer freedom
  • media research
  • claremont institute
  • foundation for the defense of democracies
  • cato institute
  • heritage foundation
  • free congress foundation
  • hoover institution
  • judicial watch
  • national center for public policy research
  • national legal and policy center
  • rutherford institute
  • home school legal defense association
  • foundation for individual rights in education
  • landmark legal foundation
  • accuracy in media
  • ludwig von mises institute
  • stratfor
  • united nations
  • u.s. central command
  • wikipedia
  • liveleak
  • youtube
  • Blogs of Note

  • lileks
  • instapundit
  • sprittibee
  • the common room
  • right wing news
  • flopping aces
  • wizbang
  • justoneminute
  • the smoking gun
  • vox popoli
  • boing boing
  • the american conservative
  • stop the aclu
  • melanie phillips
  • stand in the trenches
  • ann althouse
  • daniel pipes
  • cox & forkum
  • imao
  • pajamas media
  • musing minds
  • the daly report
  • ace of spades hq
  • joanne jacobs
  • alain's newsletter
  • newsbusters
  • what really happened
  • news with views
  • worthy news
  • aubreyj.org
  • transterrestrial musings
  • smarter than celery
  • jacklewis.net
  • freedom folks
  • scotus blog
  • Gastronomical

  • emeril's
  • paula deen
  • this mama cooks
  • food network
  • kiplog's foodblog
  • all recipes
  • chelsea market
  • Talkers

  • rush
  • hannity
  • mark levin show
  • dennis prager
  • michael reagan
  • mike gallagher
  • bill bennett
  • kim komando
  • glenn beck
  • david gold
  • kevin mccarthy
  • brian wilson
  • Talk Radio Downstreams

  • ksky (salem radio network)
  • wbap
  • wabc
  • kfi
  • krla
  • kfyi
  • ksfo
  • Online Buds

  • donald neff american artist
  • voiceover usa
  • Inspirational

  • born to win
  • ronald l. dart
  • biblestudy.org
  • lenny cacchio
  • Worthy Causes

  • salvation army
  • world vision
  • prolife across america
  • happy hill farm
  • freedom alliance scholarships
  • spirit of america
  • let's say thanks
  • smile train
  • Miscellaneous

  • lovetoknow top 10

  •  

    Thanks for stopping by and for visiting my sponsors. Hurry back!
    All pages copyright Richard Glasgow 2004-2019 All rights reserved